In September 2009, Beatrice Hernandez, a 42 year old former stripper, admitted to having been involved with former South Florida Catholic priest David Dueppen on and off for approximately seven years. The two met at Porky’s Strip Club in Hialeah, a seemingly unlikely hang out for a priest. The establishment was recently closed under charges of prostitution and the sale of illegal drugs.
Dueppen, 42, has now publicly recognized that he has in fact conceived a baby girl with Hernandez. Marilyn Epiphany was born in January 2009.
In August, Dueppen took a leave of absence from St. Maximilian Kolbe Church in Pembroke Pines, the church where he had been assigned upon joining the priesthood back in 1999. He took the bold step after Hernandez’s disclosure of the baby girl’s existence to the archdiocese. Despite his decision to take leave, Dueppen has not formally requested to fully leave the clergy although it has been reported that he is now actively searching for a job outside of the church.
According to Mary Ross Agosta, Miami Archdiocese spokeswoman, while Dueppen is unable to perform services or wear clergy attire, he is still nonetheless considered a priest on leave. Requests for permanent removal from the clergy are complicated and must be granted in Rome.
Feeling he should have primary custody of Marilyn, Dueppen has filed a lawsuit in hopes his wish will be granted. To increase his chances of winning, Dueppen has enlisted prominent attorney Ray Rafool to represent him in this sticky case. The Coral Gables attorney is well-known for his involvement with high-priced, high profile cases, in addition to his honesty, ethics and keen knowledge of Florida law.
Rafool stated Dueppen should be granted custody of the child at minimum 70 percent of the time, and explained the former priest is aware he has committed mistakes and would be the first to admit it, but still feels he is the more appropriate guardian for the child. Hernandez’s lawyer, Michael Feiler, on the other hand, explained that although his client is content by Dueppen’s acknowledgement of paternity, she is still seeking full custody of the child.
Un-conducive to Dueppen’s case is Hernandez’s allegations of domestic violence against the priest which have been passionately denied by an assertive and confident Rafool. According to the former stripper, Dueppen had become aggressive with her during a dispute regarding paternity and child support for little Marilyn, and proceeded to choke her. Hernandez does not feel comfortable with Dueppen’s excessive involvement in the child’s life given these past incidents of violence, explains Feiler.
According to Rafool, Dueppen has denied all allegations of any violent behavior on his part. Hernandez is not out of the clear either in the eyes of the court. She is still pending trial for a misdemeanor stalking charge placed upon her for the alleged harassment of a woman she supposed to be her ex-lover’s [Dueppen] new girlfriend.